Posted by: frogstale | July 10, 2014

High Conflict Personalities in Family Court

Should Mediation and Counselling Replace Today’s Family Court?

This is the question Bill Eddy asks at the High Conflict Institute.  His answer is illuminating and is something that many of us who have had to deal with ex partners with high conflict personalities (HCP) understand.

Bill recognises in particular that there is often only one person in the family court room with a HCP and they are the ones that can end up ‘winning’ because they fool the courts like they fooled us when we met them.  I highly recommend the whole article (exert reproduced below).

Disorders in the Court

Based on my experience for 12 years as a child and family therapist (Licensed Clinical Social Worker), followed by over 20 years as a family lawyer (Certified Family Law Specialist), I estimate that a majority of the clients in today’s Family Courts have a diagnosable mental health problem: substance abuse, bipolar disorder, major depression, personality disorders. For those involved in high-conflict cases, I believe that at least one party has a personality disorder because the characteristics of such a disorder are extreme interpersonal behavior, which most would consider the behaviors of abusing partners and children, hiding children, alienating children, hiding money, making false allegations and so forth. Many judges, lawyers, counselors and parents now agree with me on this.

 

It’s also important to realize that in many cases there is just one person with such a mental health disorder and in many other cases both clients have such a disorder. Therefore, it is especially important for decision-makers to understand what is going on to make accurate and protective decisions. The risk is that reasonable parents will be punished (restraining orders, supervised access with their children), while dysfunctional parents will be awarded primary custody and praised for their (hidden) misrepresentations to the court, which often encourages more dysfunctional behavior.

 

Based on research at one of the New Ways for Families programs our Institute has developed (which orders parents into short-term counseling before the big decisions are made), over 80% of high-conflict parents ordered into the program have a personality disorder. So this concern is starting to be validated by research. These are not normal families, for whom Family Courts were designed. This trend has been recognized as far back as 1997:

 

While performing our duties in all of these roles [as psychotherapists, mediators, custody evaluators], we have found that clients who engage in protracted adversarial processes, whether personal or litigious, show a high percentage of personality disorders. They make up a significant population of the descriptively difficult clients who consume an inordinate amount of time and energy of family lawyers and the family court system.”

Feinberg, R. and Greene, J.T. The Intractable Client: Guidelines for Working with Personality Disorders in Family Law, Family and Conciliation Courts Review. Vol. 35 No. 3, July 1997. 351-365.

 

The difference today is that the percentage of ordinary clients in Family Courts have significantly reduced, while the percentage of personality disordered clients has increased and may represent a majority – at least in parenting disputes.

 

Advertisements

Responses

  1. wow, that’s so true. I have often wondered what the answer is for high-conflict personalities. The problem is, they lack empathy. How are you going to get anywhere with someone who lacks empathy? They don’t have the basic understanding upon which to base the kinds of very personal decisions made in family court. I wish I had more answers and I’m happy that people are working on it.

    • The answer is to inform yourself and then work on how you are going to deal with this person, because they sure as hell aren’t going to change or take you or your children’s needs into account. Hopefully things will slowly change in the courts, too late for us now but maybe those going through the system in the future may have an easier time.

      • yes, that’s what I mean…how to deal with them in court. I am so frustrated that the courts don’t “get” it. I keep myself educated, but the system is set up to let him appeal the same issue over and over and over, and to hear his concerns. My N over-litigates to make it hard for me financially….control of course. Yes, I do hope the system changes…I want to help it change somehow.

  2. You are correct – that’s an excellent article. Courts are not the place for hashing out personal issues, yet they always arise in family law cases. I’ve read some of your other posts and I’m truly sorry that you went through all that you did. I know I could have not made it through that. No matter how you try, dealing with high-conflict and/or sociopath personality – I could not handle it.

    • You could, because you would learn to if you had to! I didn’t think I could get through this but slowly slowly, with knowledge and the support of friends and others who understand I am! I do believe in the end everyone can handle what is thrown at them because they just have to and they become better for it. Thanks for your comment.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Categories

%d bloggers like this: